Skip to Content

Exploring Life Post-Vietnam War Through ‘The Sympathizer’

Sometimes, a television adaptation of a renowned novel can effectively function as a promotional tool for the original book. This is exemplified by The Sympathizer, an HBO series based on the Pulitzer Prize-winning book by Viet Thanh Nguyen, set to premiere on Sunday. Developed in collaboration with the innovative Korean filmmaker Park Chan-wook, the series showcases numerous strengths. However, as the narrative unfolds, it becomes apparent that the profound weight of the story is perhaps best experienced through the written word. The Sympathizer delves into themes of identity navigating through historical upheavals, a narrative that may demand more introspective reflection than what television typically allows.

Nevertheless, the HBO series airing on April 14 is captivating. The Sympathizer offers a unique and essential perspective distinct from the predominantly Western-centric portrayals of the Vietnam War (referred to as the American War by the Vietnamese). Nguyen aims to expand and enrich Western understanding of the conflict and its aftermath, highlighting the autonomy, agony, and disorientation of individuals often depicted as either brutal aggressors or helpless victims. The Sympathizer presents a morally intricate narrative, eschewing simplistic notions of good and evil.

Hoa Xuande takes on the role of the Captain, a skilled and attractive operative working for the South Vietnamese secret police. He holds a respected position, serving as the loyal right-hand man to his superior, the General (Toan Le). The Captain shares a deep bond with his two childhood friends, the somewhat clumsy Bon (Fred Nguyen Khan) and the sly, elusive Man (Duy Nguyễn). Bound by a childhood pact, they navigate shifting loyalties amidst the chaos of the war’s final days in 1975 as northern forces advance towards Saigon.

The narrative evolves from an unconventional espionage tale to a portrayal of fraternal camaraderie, eventually leading to a harrowing escape from Saigon marked by tragedy, testing the Captain’s convictions. Subsequently, The Sympathizer unfolds into a discordant journey. Arriving in Los Angeles, the Captain, accompanied by Bon and the General, navigates the idiosyncrasies of American life. Despite his prior familiarity with the country from his student days, his current experience is fraught with tension and uncertainty.

The series thrives on various tensions, notably the Captain’s conflicting allegiances. Born to a Vietnamese mother and a French father, he grapples with a sense of displacement, making him an ideal candidate for the intricate double-agent role he undertakes. While adept at his clandestine duties, the Captain’s internal struggle and the blurred lines between his past and present lives begin to take a toll.

Additionally, the Captain’s covert mission unfolds akin to a nuanced spy thriller, gradually revealing the profound implications of seemingly trivial actions. Amidst the series’ blend of satire, suspense, and cultural commentary, moments of impactful violence underscore the gravity of the Captain’s obligations.

Park skillfully weaves these diverse elements together, maintaining a delicate balance between genres and themes. The series’ oscillation between personal drama, political critique, and cultural exploration is intentional, keeping viewers engaged and uncertain about the narrative’s trajectory. Through encounters with academia, Hollywood, and the challenges of immigration, the Captain grapples with his past while yearning for a sense of belonging.

Amidst the poignant exploration of displacement and longing for connection, the series occasionally injects humor, at times detracting from its emotional depth. The portrayal of powerful white figures by Robert Downey, Jr. underscores themes of colonialism and exploitation, though occasionally bordering on caricature.

However, the series falters in its finale, veering towards hallucinatory abstraction that muddles the narrative when clarity is needed most. Despite this, The Sympathizer remains a thought-provoking and dynamic series. While it may not fully capture the literary richness of its source material, it presents a compelling and challenging viewing experience. By reimagining a turbulent era through a distinct narrative lens, The Sympathizer compels viewers to engage deeply with its characters and themes, offering a fresh perspective on a tumultuous period in history.