Skip to Content

Life on the Front Lines of American Wildfires: The Great Burnout

ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom dedicated to uncovering abuses of power, is at the forefront of investigative journalism. Stay informed by signing up to receive their latest publications.

With the rise in unprecedented wildfires, the responsibilities placed on wildland firefighters have never been more demanding. This year, the Smokehouse Creek Fire in the Texas Panhandle emerged as the second-largest wildfire in U.S. history, scorching nearly 1.1 million acres. Similarly, the Lahaina fire in Maui last year, though part of a relatively calm fire season, marked Hawaii’s largest wildfire with a tragic death toll of at least 100. The challenges persist, as seen in New Mexico experiencing its largest and second-largest fires simultaneously in recent years — the Hermits Peak-Calf Canyon Fire up north and the Black Fire down south.

Despite the escalating threats, the backbone of America’s firefighting efforts is showing signs of strain. A recent investigation by ProPublica revealed a significant attrition rate of 45% among permanent wildland firefighting staff over the past three years. This investigation shed light on the hurdles faced by these firefighters, including prolonged separations from their families, an organizational structure indifferent to their well-being, and a complex payment system that inadvertently encourages risk-taking.

In response to inquiries about the high attrition rate, a Forest Service representative acknowledged that the agency has lost firefighters to better-paying positions, particularly in certain regions and states.

The critical situation in the fire-prone West underscores the urgency for action. The Hermits Peak-Calf Canyon Fire in 2022, stemming from a controlled burn gone awry, exemplifies the dire consequences of such incidents. ProPublica, in collaboration with Source New Mexico, extensively covered the aftermath of this catastrophic event, highlighting delays in compensating victims and the struggles faced by survivors in seeking restitution for both economic and non-economic damages.

Efforts to enhance safety measures within the U.S. Forest Service are underway following the wildfire incidents. FEMA’s role has also evolved to address the aftermath, with a claims office set up to distribute funds from a $4 billion allocation, albeit with only a fraction disbursed thus far.

A recent roundtable discussion organized by ProPublica, Source New Mexico, and Outside Magazine brought together key stakeholders to delve into these pressing issues. The conversation delved into the reasons behind firefighter attrition, the challenges of post-fire recovery efforts, and the need for systemic improvements.

In an interview derived from this event, various experts shared insights on the evolving landscape of firefighting and disaster recovery. The dialogue underscored the urgent need for transparency, improved hazard pay structures, and comprehensive health protections for wildland firefighters.

The collaborative investigation by ProPublica and Source New Mexico also scrutinized FEMA’s response to the Hermits Peak-Calf Canyon Fire aftermath, revealing bureaucratic hurdles and delays in compensating affected individuals. The stories of individuals like Yolanda Cruz, who faced property losses and bureaucratic challenges, shed light on the long road to recovery for many impacted by the wildfires.

As the affected communities strive to rebuild and recover, the experiences from these disasters emphasize the importance of preparedness, efficient disaster response mechanisms, and equitable compensation for those affected. The lessons learned underscore the need for robust emergency management plans and a reevaluation of FEMA’s capacity to handle large-scale disasters effectively.