Skip to Content

Inside Lev Tahor: Witness Chronicles a Harrowing Tale of Control and Escape

The Escape from Lev Tahor

In September 2018, Shimon Malka made a decisive escape from Lev Tahor, an ultra-Orthodox Jewish sect then located in Guatemala, which he had grown increasingly disillusioned with due to its oppressive practices. At just 62 years old and undernourished from stringent food restrictions that left him weighing a mere 80 pounds, Malka’s departure marked a significant turning point. He left behind his life within the sect, which was characterized by harsh living conditions and troubling treatment of minors, to seek a healthier and more autonomous existence.

The Kidnapping Plot Unfolds

Despite his initial escape, Malka found himself entangled in a grave situation two months later when he was persuaded to partake in a kidnapping orchestrated by the sect’s leaders. The plan was to abduct the 14-year-old granddaughter and the 12-year-old grandson of the sect’s founder, whose mother had fled the community. As a key witness in the federal trial against three members of the Weingarten family, who were deeply involved in the sect, Malka provided critical testimony detailing his role in facilitating the kidnapping by providing a secret cellphone to one of the children involved.

Life After Lev Tahor

Malka’s testimony extended beyond the kidnapping, shedding light on the daily realities of life within Lev Tahor. He spoke of the stringent controls imposed by the sect’s leadership over personal freedoms, from marriage to financial decisions. His account painted a vivid picture of the physical and psychological control exerted over members, including forced marriages of young girls and severe punishments for disobedience. His brave disclosures helped articulate the dire circumstances he escaped from and highlighted the broader implications of such insular communities on individual rights and welfare.

Additional Insights:

The trial of the Weingarten brothers not only focused on the specific act of kidnapping but also offered a rare glimpse into the internal workings of Lev Tahor, challenging the narrative that the community was merely preserving religious traditions. Through Malka’s detailed account, the jury was able to see the manipulation and abuse that often lurked behind the community’s secluded existence. This case has brought significant attention to the need for vigilance and stricter oversight in similar religious communities to prevent the exploitation of vulnerable members, especially children. Malka’s transition from a controlled life within Lev Tahor to a free individual highlights the profound impact that such communities can have on personal autonomy and underscores the importance of support systems for those who manage to break free.