Skip to Content

Review of Amy Winehouse’s Turbulent Life in ‘Back To Black’

Title: Back To Black
Distributor: Focus Features
Director: Sam Taylor-Johnson
Screenwriter: Matt Greenhalgh
Cast: Marisa Abela, Jack O’Connell, Eddie Marsan, Lesley Manville
Rating: R
Running time: 2 hr 2 min

In the ‘unofficial’ 2009 John Lennon biopic Nowhere Boy, the scarcity of music forced the film to rely heavily on the opening chord of “Hard Day’s Night.” The narrative surrounding Back to Black, a brief yet impactful portrayal of Amy Winehouse, initially seemed poised for a similar reliance on music. However, contrary to expectations, the Winehouse estate fully embraced the project. While some may argue that the film slightly sanitizes the singer’s tumultuous life, there remains a raw authenticity that sets it apart. It stands as a rare cinematic piece that empowers a female figure in the rock’n’roll scene, offering a unique perspective akin to a reverse Sid & Nancy.

Typically, music biopics face the challenge of conforming to established facts while adding depth for both informed audiences and newcomers. Back to Black encounters this familiar hurdle but manages to sidestep the constraints of conventional timeline markers, a choice that may resonate less with international viewers unfamiliar with the UK’s cultural landscape. The film delves into Winehouse’s world through her own lens, evading the pitfalls of a conventional rise-and-fall narrative. Unlike the documentary Amy, which meticulously dissected Winehouse’s life, Back to Black embraces her flaws and self-destructive tendencies without glossing over them, offering a nuanced portrayal that defies simplistic interpretations.

The core of the narrative revolves around Winehouse’s tumultuous relationship with Blake Fielder-Civil, a figure who escapes significant scrutiny in the film. Played by Jack O’Connell, Fielder-Civil emerges as a pivotal influence in Winehouse’s public unraveling, highlighting her vulnerability to destructive patterns. The film subtly challenges the notion of external blame, emphasizing Winehouse’s agency in her own choices amidst a backdrop of media scrutiny and personal struggles. Through the lens of a relative newcomer in the lead role, the film captures moments of unfiltered authenticity, showcasing Winehouse’s evolution into the iconic figure she became.

Despite the rich material at hand, Back to Black concludes on a somber note, eschewing a sensationalized climax for a more introspective resolution. It defies categorization, refraining from a singular focus on fame, wealth, or addiction. Instead, it offers a multifaceted portrait of an artist often oversimplified in popular narratives, akin to the complexity embodied by the tattoo of Betty Boop adorning Winehouse’s back. While the musical biopic format may not fully capture her essence, the film hints at the potential for a powerful operatic adaptation in the future.