The peculiar yet true story of Elmer McCurdy (1880-1911), a lesser-known outlaw turned sideshow exhibit, first caught David Yazbek’s attention nearly three decades ago. This Oklahoma outlaw’s journey from failed bank and train robberies to a mummified attraction in sideshows across America is both eerie and fascinating. His remains, which were painted a vivid red and displayed in a California amusement park’s house of horrors, were discovered to be real during an accidental mishap by a TV crew in 1976. This discovery prompted a deeper investigation into McCurdy’s past and identity. Moved by these events, Yazbek, alongside his friend and fellow musician Erik Della Penna, created a song cycle that evolved into a stage musical with the help of playwright Itamar Moses and director David Cromer. Their collaboration brought “Dead Outlaw” to life at Audible’s Minetta Lane Theatre, marking a bold entry into musical theater for Audible.
The musical “Dead Outlaw” skillfully weaves its narrative through direct narrations, emotionally potent songs, and fragmented scenes portraying key events from McCurdy’s life, segmented into “The Life of Elmer McCurdy” and “The Death of Elmer McCurdy.” It begins with a prologue that sets the tone with its first number “Dead,” introducing the audience to McCurdy’s impending death, and ends with a moving funeral procession and burial in 1977, explored in an epilogue. The recurring musical themes highlight the inevitability of death, emphasizing the universal themes of legacy and mortality.
An outstanding cast of eight, featuring Jeb Brown, Eddie Cooper, Dashiell Eaves, Julia Knitel, Ken Marks, Trent Saunders, Thom Sesma, and led by Andrew Durand as McCurdy, bring dynamic energy and versatility to the stage. Under the musical direction of Rebekah Bruce, the performers and a five-piece band navigate a variety of musical styles, blending humor and sorrow with reflective moments that engage the audience deeply. Durand’s portrayal of McCurdy is particularly compelling, offering a sympathetic look at his complex life marked by misadventures and unrealized dreams. The production artfully mixes elements of reality and fiction, prompting reflections on the essence of notoriety, exploitation, and our own mortality.
The musical’s rich atmospheric elements, including Arnulfo Maldonado’s set design and the period-specific costumes, draw the audience into the Old West, enhancing the immersive experience. Audiences can look forward to both the live performances at Minetta Lane Theatre and an upcoming Audible recording, promising a powerful and introspective look into a man’s life and legacy that challenges traditional storytelling forms.
Additional Information:
Experiencing “Dead Outlaw” live or through its anticipated audio recording promises to leave audiences contemplating the intricate tapestry of human life and the cultural dimensions of death and fame. This production not only offers a deep dive into historical contexts but also resonates with contemporary themes of identity and personal history. By engaging with this unique theatrical presentation, viewers are invited to explore the profound and often unsettling realities of how history remembers us. This blend of history with theatrical innovation provides a compelling reason not to miss this profound exploration of Elmer McCurdy’s life and posthumous journey.